The Guardian perspective on graduates and employment: degrees though not destinations

For all those gripped by dejection over a steel predicament and wondering what it is precisely that Britain creates any more, this journal has an answer. The UK leads a universe in production graduates. Per head, it churns out some-more degree-holders than Germany, Austria, Norway, Switzerland or Spain. From 19% of propagandize leavers entering aloft preparation in 1989, to 47% now, a UK has seen a biggest enlargement of a university attention anywhere in Europe. That is generally remarkable, given a shake-ups to a admissions procession and financing, and a outrageous arise in costs.

Yet that expansion mostly lets down a immature people indeed going by a aloft preparation mill. It leaves them brimful with debt, and as supervision total demonstrated final week, mostly in practice that conjunction draws on their skills nor pays their way. All this is not what unbroken governments promised. From John Major to Tony Blair to David Cameron, primary apportion after primary apportion has urged immature people into university, charity in lapse a sheet to tip jobs. They also hoped it would make a economy some-more dynamic, as in this 2006 central report for Gordon Brown’s Treasury: “The UK contingency turn a universe personality in skills. Skills is a many critical push within a control to emanate resources and revoke amicable deprivation.”

Well, a UK is now a universe personality in “skills”. It has, on paper, a many learned workforce a nation has ever had. Yet demeanour during a latest central connoisseur work marketplace statistics, that uncover that roughly one in three, 31%, of all graduates are not doing connoisseur – or high-skilled – jobs. To be clear, on normal it still does compensate to go to university. The news shows that immature graduates are some-more expected to be employed and are paid an normal of £6,000 a year some-more than those with no degree. But a “graduate premium” – a additional volume a connoisseur can design for those 3 or some-more years – is narrowing. And black graduates are quite feeble served by aloft preparation – customarily 37% of them are in connoisseur jobs.

Some in a higher-education run competence explain this reflects an economy still intoxicated from a issue of a banking predicament and a prolonged slump. But this unusual mismatch between graduates and connoisseur jobs was seemingly manifest before a crash. Two economists during a University of Kent looked during what happened to graduates in a jobs marketplace between 1992 and 2006, that is from a issue of a ERM predicament by a prolonged bang of a Blair years. They found that a third of graduates were “overqualified”, doing work that wouldn’t customarily need a university degree. One out of each 10 graduates was “really overqualified” – doing a pursuit that didn’t use any of their dear university training. Employers now sinecure graduates for work that formerly didn’t need a degree: estate agents, military officers, nurses.

The government’s response to all this will shortly emerge in a aloft preparation bill. But already this month, a No 10 lecture paper was held on prolonged lens camera acknowledging that “Education opposite a spectrum – from some in a Russell organisation … by FE [further education] colleges – do not offer a peculiarity and power of training we design for 9k.” Their answer will substantially be to arrange degrees by how most their students can design to acquire during a end. As Andrew McGettigan, author of a new Great University Gamble, predicts, this could open a approach to holding a £9,000 top off fees altogether. “Better” faculties will afterwards be means to assign students whatever their managers consider a marketplace will bear. Yet whatever a failings of some university departments, it’s transparent that ministers are also to censure – for presiding over a low-pay, low-productivity jobs marketplace that simply isn’t fit for a splendid immature things being launched into it.

About admin